The Power of Critique Groups (and How to Find One)
One of the greatest assets a writer can have is not just talent, perseverance, or even luck—it’s community. And at the heart of a thriving writing community is something essential to every writer’s growth: a critique group.
A good critique group can be the cornerstone of a writer’s development, offering encouragement, feedback, accountability, and fresh perspective. Whether you’re just starting out or are a seasoned author, joining (or forming) a critique group can elevate your craft, deepen your understanding of storytelling, and move your projects toward publication faster and more effectively than working alone.
Why Critique Groups Matter
Writing is a solitary act—but publishing is not.
When you’re deeply immersed in your own story, it can be almost impossible to see its blind spots. A good critique group acts as a mirror and a sounding board. Fellow writers can point out inconsistencies, identify plot holes, catch confusing language, and offer ideas you might never have considered.
More importantly, critique groups offer motivation. Knowing that others are waiting to read your latest work can help you meet deadlines and maintain momentum. They also provide a critical reminder that rejection is not personal—it’s part of the process—and they celebrate your wins along the way.
Some of the most successful authors credit their critique partners as being instrumental in their journey to publication. I don’t know what I would do without mine! It’s no exaggeration to say that a great critique group can change your writing life.
What Makes a Great Critique Group?
Not all critique groups are created equal. The best ones share a few key traits:
- Trust and Respect: Members give honest, constructive feedback while respecting each writer’s voice and vision.
- Commitment: Regular meetings and active participation help build momentum and foster genuine growth.
- Balance of Positivity and Challenge: A good critique partner points out both what’s working and what could be improved, balancing encouragement with honest suggestions.
- Shared Goals: It helps if members are writing in similar genres or for similar audiences, or at least share a common level of commitment to their craft.
- Professionalism: Punctuality, preparation, and thoughtful critiques make a group feel purposeful and productive.
How to Find (or Start) a Critique Group
If you’re ready to experience the benefits of a critique group, here are several ways to find one:
Professional Organizations:
Membership in the Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators (SCBWI) can help connect you with others via their conferences and local chapter events.
Online Communities:
Platforms like 12×12 and Kidlit411 can be a terrific resource for critique partner matching.
Writers’ Workshops and Classes:
If you’re taking a writing course—whether through a university, online platform, or a writing conference—chances are many of your classmates would love to form a critique group.
Local Libraries and Bookstores:
Many libraries and indie bookstores host writing groups or bulletin boards where you can find other local writers looking for critique partners.
Start Your Own:
If you can’t find the right group, consider starting one! Reach out to writers you know, or post a call in local community spaces or online groups.
Tips for Successful Critiquing
Once you’re part of a group, it’s important to make the most of the experience—for yourself and others. Here are some helpful groundrules:
- Be Specific: Vague feedback (“I liked it” or “Something felt off”) isn’t helpful. Focus on specific elements like pacing, character development, voice, or dialogue.
- Be Kind but Honest: Always frame feedback in a way that’s helpful, not hurtful. Think of it as helping the writer strengthen their story, not tearing it down. Try the complement sandwich approach.
- Focus on Questions: Rather than offering suggestions or criticism, focus on asking questions about any areas or issues that are unclear or could use further work. This can lead the writer to finding their own answers.
- Be Open to Receiving Critique: It’s natural to feel a little defensive when others critique your work—but remember, they’re there to help. Keep an open mind and consider suggestions carefully, even if you don’t take every piece of advice.
- Respect Differences: Every writer has a different voice and vision. Critique with the goal of helping them achieve their vision—not rewriting the story the way you would write it.
So if you haven’t yet found your people—start looking. They’re out there, waiting to read your stories and help you make them the best they can be.
