What Makes a Picture Book Work? A Layered Look
When a picture book works—really works—it feels almost effortless. The story flows, the voice sings, and the art and text come together in perfect harmony. But behind that seemingly simple surface lies a delicate, deliberate layering of craft.
As writers, we often focus on one or two elements at a time—perhaps polishing our prose or refining our structure. But to truly elevate a manuscript, it helps to think in layers. Just like a great dish or a beautifully composed painting, a great picture book is multidimensional.
Let’s break down the layers I most often refer to when editing or teaching:
- Structure – Is there a clear beginning, middle, and end? Does the narrative build? Whether you’re working with a traditional arc, a concept structure, or something more experimental, structure forms the foundation.
- Theme – What’s your story really about? Underneath the plot, is there an emotional or philosophical truth that gives the story resonance? This is the layer that sticks with readers long after the last page.
- Pacing – Do the page turns create surprise, suspense, or reflection? Are moments given the breathing room they deserve, or is the story rushing—or dragging—along?
- Heart – This is that ineffable quality that invites connection. Often tied to theme, but more personal. Does the story come from an authentic place? Does it evoke feeling?
- Voice and Language – Is the voice distinctive? Are the words musical, intentional, and child-centered? Language should do more than convey meaning—it should delight the ear.
- Illustration Potential – Are you leaving space for the illustrator to tell part of the story? Are you inviting collaboration with the visual storytelling?
When these layers align and support each other, the manuscript lifts off the page.
The best part? You don’t have to get them all perfect at once. Revision is where the layering really happens. So if you’re stuck or feeling uncertain, ask yourself: which layer needs strengthening?
